Skip to main content

The Milburn report: You cannot sanction someone into a job that doesn’t exist

Our Students

Professor Emese Lazar, Professor of Finance:

“The Milburn report is a welcome and ambitious step forward. It tackles the economic and social challenge of youth unemployment head-on, with a clear focus on practical solutions, and it is right to warn that inaction carries risks beyond financial cost, including the potential for wider social strain.

“The report’s proposal for a targeted subsidy to help employers create new jobs is a sensible direction. The alternative of cutting National Insurance contributions would be less balanced in terms of cost and benefit, with high costs and less tangible benefits. Ideally, the subsidy should be paid in instalments rather than as a single payment, so that funding is tied to keeping young people in work over the longer term.

“The estimated £200 million net saving over ten years, from reduced benefit payments and increased tax revenue, is only part of the picture. It is a modest margin and should not be the yardstick for the scheme. The main benefit lies beyond the financials: more young people in employment, with the lasting gains in skills, income, wellbeing and prospects that follow. These social benefits are likely to be considerably greater than the fiscal return, though they will take time to materialise.

“There are also real costs to inaction. Young people who are out of work cost the state in benefits and weigh on the wider economy, so the long-term cost of not investing in them could well exceed the cost of helping them into work.”

Professor Benjamin Laker, Professor of Leadership:

"Britain has a first-job problem, not simply a young-people problem. We have created a labour market in which employers increasingly expect experience from people who have never been given the opportunity to acquire it.

“The proposed National Insurance cuts are welcome, but making young people cheaper to employ doesn't automatically make businesses more willing to invest in them. The danger is that we spend billions subsidising recruitment without addressing why so many employers have stopped developing their own future workforce. And with artificial intelligence increasingly capable of performing the routine tasks traditionally given to junior employees, that first rung on the career ladder risks disappearing altogether.

"There is also something fundamentally uncomfortable about threatening young people with benefit sanctions when employers themselves are retreating from entry-level recruitment. You cannot sanction someone into a job that doesn't exist. A genuine guarantee of work or training could be transformative, but only if meaningful opportunities are actually available. Otherwise, we risk blaming an entire generation for a labour market they did not create.

"The real test of Milburn's reforms will not be how many young people leave the benefits system, but how many are still building successful careers five years later."

Dr Adeyinka Adewale, Associate Professor of Leadership Ethics and Entrepreneurship:

“Milburn’s legal “opportunity guarantee” is an understandable response to a million young people outside education, employment or training, and a first job can open doors. But a million NEETs are not a million idle young people. Many are actively looking for work, volunteering or in transition, and this generation sees work differently. Around seven in ten say they are drawn to running their own venture. A blanket arrangement that funnels them into any vacancy risks misreading those strengths and stifling the entrepreneurial capacity our economy needs.

"Success cannot be measured only by benefits saved and taxes paid. The task is to find young people meaningful work, where they learn to spot problems, take initiative and create value. This is how today and tomorrow’s job creators are made.”

Dr Miriam Marra, Associate Professor of Finance:

"Milburn’s NEET report sets an ambitious goal: cut the rate from 13% to 5% by 2036. But targets alone won’t change lives. We need sustained investments, practical support and real pathways into education, training and work. An effort not only from the Government, but also from employers, older generations of employees, schools, universities and families to respond to this wake-up call."

To speak with any of our business, finance and leadership academic experts, email pr@henley.ac.uk or call +44 (0)118 378 8676.

Professor Emese Lazar

Head of Pre-Experience Postgraduate Programmes

Professor Benjamin Laker

Professor of Leadership

Dr Adeyinka Adewale

Associate Professor of Leadership Ethics and Entrepreneurship
Published 17 November 2026
Topics:
Leading insights